In recent years, the concept of identity has evolved within various business operations. The functions of identity have historically ranged  from I-9 verifications in human resources to the marketing strategies targeting customer demographics to the methodologies employed by fraud detection teams. More recently, identity has become a central focus in digital marketing as it relates more and more to how someone exists in the “real world.”

This shift has been largely propelled by the exponential growth of digital life, where individuals’ digital footprints and the commodification of personal data have facilitated a unique economic exchange. This exchange, often described as an unspoken quid pro quo relationship, involves consumers providing their data in return for free access to content or services, thereby fueling the advertising industry and driving digital commerce. Examples include Facebook or subscription-free websites like CNN – both are nominally “free,” but track user behavior to sell targeted advertising.

The advent of paid subscriptions and premium content tiers has recently led consumers to question the value they receive in exchange for their personal information, sparking a privacy backlash as the public has grown more knowledgeable about how their data is harvested and used. The growing skepticism around data privacy has raised important questions about the future of identity in the digital age: Should an individual’s digital footprint be inextricably linked to their real-life identifiers? Who is responsible for managing and safeguarding this digital identity? Moreover, how should the commercial world adapt if the foundational ‘handshake’ agreement between consumers and content providers disintegrates?

Challenges for Businesses

As the foundational understanding of digital identity shifts, businesses face significant challenges, particularly those heavily reliant on direct data access for targeted advertising. The potential redefinition of digital identity and growing demands for privacy are leading to a loss of direct access to consumer data. This poses a considerable dilemma for businesses that have historically depended on this data to drive their revenue.

The shift towards more traditional, and more expensive, advertising models seems inevitable. Without the precise targeting facilitated by direct data access, businesses may need to revert to broader advertising strategies that could lead to increased marketing costs. Moreover, the disintegration of the ‘handshake’ agreement between consumers and content providers could necessitate a reevaluation of how value is exchanged in the digital realm. Businesses might need to explore alternative models of engagement that respect consumer privacy while still providing personalized experiences. This transition could involve substantial investment in technology and processes to safeguard digital identity, further increasing operational costs.

Marketing Technology News: MarTech Interview with Noel Hamill, CMO @ parcelLab

Impact on Consumers

Consumers, for their part, might need to brace for the ripple effects of these shifts. Particularly pertinent is the question of whether the indirect revenue from data monetization is no longer viable. As businesses grapple with increased operational costs due to the need for more traditional advertising methods and investments in privacy-compliant technologies, these costs could potentially be passed on to consumers. This could manifest in the form of higher prices for goods and services or more paid subscriptions and premium content offerings, altering the landscape of free access to digital content that many have come to expect.

The Balance Between Privacy, Identity, and Commerce

The ongoing discourse around digital identity, privacy, and data use highlights the need for a balanced approach that safeguards individual privacy while sustaining the digital economy. Businesses must be proactive in adopting practices that ensure the ethical collection, use, and protection of personal data, fostering trust and transparency with their consumers.

Furthermore, the industry needs to embrace regulatory frameworks that support this balance, providing clear guidelines for businesses and rights for consumers. Such frameworks should encourage innovation and ethical fair use while protecting individuals from unwanted surveillance.

Looking Ahead

The redefinition of digital identity and the associated challenges and opportunities necessitate a collective effort from businesses, consumers, and regulators. It is an opportunity to reimagine the foundations of digital commerce, prioritizing ethical data use and privacy without stifling innovation. As we navigate these changes, the critical role of transparent, ethical data use in sustaining the future of the digital economy cannot be overstated. The journey towards a more privacy-conscious digital world is complex, but with thoughtful engagement and collaboration, it is possible to strike a balance that respects privacy, identity, and commerce in equal measure.

Marketing Technology News: Why we must Address Confusion and Complexity in the CDP Market 

Also catch; Episode 191 of The SalesStar Podcast: The Future of Online Shopping with Anh Vu-Lieberman, VP of Conversion Rate and Optimization at Nogin