Quality Products Logo Survey: Most Catchiest, Annoying, Hated, Misheard Advertising Jingles Ranked

What’s the common entity between a slogan, a piece of music, and a logo? It’s the quick recognition and the immediate attention from the brain towards it. In advertising, we hear jingles that rhyme, which tries to associate the best possible connection of a brand to the customers. It doesn’t matter whether it is annoying, pleasing, or happy, a strategically designed jingle can get stuck inside the mind of the consumers, whether they want it to not. And whether people love them or despise them, there’s no denying that advertising jingles have been a part of marketing culture for a very long time. They are quick, under 60 seconds, most of the time 15-30 seconds, and possess the power to carry the product to worldwide fame.

Perceiving the power of advertising jingles, Quality Products Logo surveyed 735 U.S. residents to share their impressions of 67 advertising melodies. The survey was conducted online and involved 48 states and the District of Columbia, excluding Hawaii and North Dakota. Respondent’s ages ranged from 18 to 75, with a median age of 35. The questionnaire entailed a mix of multiple-choice, short answer, fill-in-the-blank, and rating scale formats. To prevent ballot fatigue, not all participants were exposed to the same jingles. However, each jingle was evaluated at least 164 times.

Here’s what they found.

Key Findings of the ‘Jingles’ Project:

• “Nationwide is on your side” was the best-known jingle, recognized by 92.6% of survey respondents. It was followed closely by McDonald’s “Ba-da-ba-ba-baaa… I’m lovin’ it” and the canyon-crossing cry of “Ricola!”
• The top 10 most recognizable jingles are all attached to brands between 50 and 100 years old. Five of those jingles themselves reach back to the 1960s.
• Insurance firm jingles were immediately known to roughly half the survey’s respondents. All four insurance jingles — Nationwide, State Farm, Farmers, and Liberty Mutual — placed in the top third of the pack for recognizability.
• The Folgers coffee jingle placed second in the most likeable and catchiest categories, and near the top for recognizability, as well.
• Chili’s “baby back ribs” ditty won the title for catchiest jingle. Following in second and third place were Folgers’ timeless rhyme and the über-simple Ricola yodel.
• The repetitive jingle for Liberty Mutual tops both the most hated and the most annoying lists — but it also lands in the top 10 for catchiest.
• The jingle for Sara Lee is by far the most commonly misheard, with 74.6% of people thinking the lyrics are, “Nobody does it like Sara Lee.”

Stickiest Dittiest: The Jingles Americans Remember Best

Based on the criteria of “Definitely remember, ”Maybe remember,” and “Doesn’t ring a bell” columns, Quality Logo Products used a weighted average for responses and analyzed how recognizable each jingle was to the survey respondents.

Top results included:

• Nationwide sits at 54.7% ‘Definitely Remember’ category and weighted average of 1.47 with a slogan that was birthed in 1964. It has become one of the best advertising slogans of all time.
• The place was also shared by McDonald’s with 54.9% ‘Definitely Remember’ with a weighted average of 1.43. Its “Ba-da-ba-ba-baaa … loving it” was the most recent and was introduced in 2003.
• Ricola scored third place with 51.7% and 1.43 weighted average.

For the full list click here.

Most Likeable Jingles of All the Time

For the most liked jingles, McDonald’s “I’m lovin’ it” jingle was at the top of the Like List, too. People love it most for its chirpy tune and simple, positive message, rating it a 4.39 out of 5 for likeability. It was followed by Folgers’ timeless morning anthem with a score of 4.34. Band-Aid’s “I am stuck on Band-Aid“ and Oscar Mayer’s “My bologna has a first name“ campaigns and Kit Kat’s “Gimme a break… break me off a piece of that Kit Kat bar”, rounded out the top five.

Catchiest Jingles of All Time

The catchiest one was bestowed to Chili’s “baby back ribs” ditty with a score of 4.33 out of 5. Following right behind in second and third place were the time-honored Folgers rhyme with 4.32 and the über-simple Ricola call with 4.31. Half-spoken and only semi-melodic with six notes, the alliterative “Maybe it’s Maybelline” campaign made a surprise showing in fourth place, with the punchy, repetitive “Ch-ch-ch-Chia” Pet rounding out the top five catchiest jingles.

Most Hated Jingles of All Time

Surveyors hate Liberty Mutual jingle “Liberty, Liberty, Liberty … Liberty” the most with a rating of 3.14. Followed by Pepsi Cola’s “Have a Pepsi Day” and Ragu’s “I feel like chicken tonight, like chicken tonight” sitting at 3.41. The Army’s iconic “Be all that you can be” theme got it the fourth spot.

Most Annoying Jingles of All Time

Liberty Mutual won in this category besides being the most hated jingle of all time, which also ranked at 10th for catchiest. This result comes as evidence that ‘annoying doesn’t necessarily mean ineffective’. The tune for Nestlé’s Wonderball, an amped-up cover of the 1958 hit song “Book of Love,” won second most annoying honors. The second-most-hated “Have a Pepsi day” jingle placed third for being annoying. In addition to Liberty Mutual and Pepsi, both qualities are shared by the jingles for J.G. Wentworth and Reese’s Puffs cereal.

Most Misheard Jingle of All Time

Sara Lee’s “Nobody doesn’t like Sara Lee!” was the most misheard jingle of all time with 74.6% of listeners getting the lyrics wrong — “Nobody does it like Sara Lee!”

The survey further dives deep into the brands, campaign history, and psychology & science behind jingles. It also shows a roadmap of what makes a good jingle.