Ecommerce marketers are 2x more likely to choose UGC over AI-generated content when asked which type of visual content earns the most consumer trust suggests a new survey from Nosto

A new survey pinpoints the key challenges that today’s ecommerce brands face in their visual marketing. 90%(1) admit it’s a struggle generating images and videos that stand out from their competitors, 87% (1) note the difficulty of maintaining a constant flow of fresh marketing imagery and 83% (1) point to the challenge of ensuring their visual content supports diversity across race, gender, age, size, and physical ability. 84% (1) also said managing the cost of professional photo shoots and influencer content is challenging.

The survey of 202 ecommerce marketers by Nosto, the Commerce Experience Platform, suggests many businesses are turning to content that’s created and freely shared online by their customers. 87% (1) say it’s now easier to launch and scale marketing campaigns using this vast pool of high-quality visual User Generated Content (UGC).

81% (1) of marketers in the survey believe visual UGC resonates more with customers than either professionally shot photos or influencer content. 87% (1) think it’s a more authentic way to ensure diversity in their marketing than handpicking models and influencers. And, 85% (1) agree that visual UGC minimizes costs compared to using professional photography or influencer content.

Damien Mahoney, Chief Strategy Officer of Nosto, said: “For ecommerce marketers, the demand for fresh, high-quality imagery is relentless. You need visuals for ads across multiple channels, in organic and paid social and on your website. Not only has this content got to stand out from the competition, but it needs to be continually refreshed as people soon tire of seeing the same imagery. Not only this, but promoting diversity in visual marketing is becoming a priority, with research from Deloitte suggesting 38% of high-growth brands now actively measure diversity in their brand messaging and imagery. In sectors such as fashion and beauty in particular, showcasing diversity is increasingly important.”

“Many ecommerce brands are now realizing that part of the answer to these challenges is staring them in the face: use the positive images and videos your customers are already happily sharing about your company and its products on social media.”

Visual UGC beats AI-generated content for customer trust

While there is plenty of excitement about the potential to use AI-generated images and videos for marketing, the survey suggests trust is a significant barrier for AI. When ecommerce marketers were asked which visual content generated the most customer trust, visual UGC came top (33%), with more than double the number of marketers believing it delivered the most trust than AI-generated visuals (16%). UGC was followed by professional images and video (24%) and influencer-generated visuals (18%), with stock photos/videos the least trusted at 8%.

Which visual content generates the most customer trust?

• Images/video from real customers (user-generated content) – 33%
• Professionally shot images/video – 24%
• Influencer-generated images/video – 18%
• AI-generated photos/video – 16%
• Stock photos/video – 8%

Where do ecommerce brands go to find the best quality visual UGC?

In Nosto’s research, 84% of participants said that identifying and sourcing visual UGC is challenging. So, where should ecommerce companies go to find high-quality customer-generated imagery? It depends on the individual brand and where its customers share their content. Most (28%) of the ecommerce marketers in the survey think Instagram generates the most engaging visual UGC for their customers, followed by Facebook (23%) and TikTok (19%). Next came YouTube (17%) and Twitter/X (10%).

Marketing Technology News: MarTech Interview with Tobyn Sowden, CEO at Redbrick

Which social media platform produces the most engaging visual UGC?

• Instagram – 28%
• Facebook – 23%
• TikTok – 19%
• YouTube – 17%
• Twitter/X – 10%

“Many brands start by identifying and curating the visual content their customers already post on social platforms such as Instagram,” said Damien Mahoney. “The next stage is more proactive—you encourage customers to post more images and videos with competitions and incentives and secure the rights to use these visual assets across your marketing. Many brands are now actively nurturing communities of their biggest customer advocates, giving them specific briefs for visual content for upcoming campaigns. While brands might hesitate to get customers too heavily involved in their marketing, leaning on a customer community like this can sometimes produce creative visual themes that might not occur to the brands themselves.”

The survey sample included ecommerce retailers in North America and the UK in the Fashion & Accessories, Health & Beauty, Home, Garden & DIY, Consumer Electronics and Food & Drink verticals with annual sales revenue of $50m and above. All the participants had used visual UGC in their marketing.

Marketing Technology News: Top 10 Digital Marketing Tools for Busy CMOs